The IMF seems to have turned significantly more pessimistic on the prospect of a Spanish recovery. The charts below provide a comparison with the previous WEO forecasts (highlighting how these forecasts tend to be overly optimistic) - which very much confirms what we have noted before about the real risks in Spain.
The latest projections for the Spanish deficit (the dark blue line in the above chart) definitely represent a break from previous forecasts. In particular, the forecast for 2014 is 2.3% of GDP higher than in October. The IMF says this is:
“Reflecting the worse unemployment outlook and the lack of specified medium-term measures.”Translation: the government does not have the necessary budget cuts and reforms in place to meet its desired deficit path – step it up Rajoy.
Such an increase manifests itself in the debt level projections as well. Worryingly, these no longer peak in 2015/16 and level off thereafter. Instead, Spanish debt to GDP is forecast to reach 111% in 2018 and looks set to keep growing rather than peaking and levelling off.
Effectively, this graph also highlights how the forecasts have progressed as the crisis in Spain has evolved from from financial, to a sovereign liquidity crisis and now into a sovereign solvency one. As the IMF notes, sustaining this will be tough:
“[Countries such as Spain] would need to maintain large primary surpluses over the medium term. In the absence of entitlement reforms, projected increases in age-related spending mean that additional measures will still be needed over time, however, to keep the primary surplus constant.”Translation: Spain needs to run large primary surpluses for a long time, but in the face of increasing welfare and pension spending, this will need to come from a series of additional and painful cuts.
So the IMF does not paint a pretty picture for Spain. Longer and deeper recession, larger deficits at a time when it needs to be moving to surplus and increasing debt, in turn raising questions about the country's solvency. Let’s not forget, that’s before bringing the bust banking sector into the discussion. Plenty for Rajoy to get on with then…
Update 16:20 18/04/13:
Christine Lagarde has reportedly suggested that Spain should be allowed to ease its austerity programme. Lagarde argues that, although Spain needs fiscal consolidation, it does not need to be front loaded. Such an argument is not going to sit well with the eurozone and will increase the tensions within the Troika (some of which were outlined in this FT article earlier today). As the graph below shows such an approach may not fit well with the IMF own growth forecasts. Even with a 7% deficit, growth next year in Spain will be 0.7% according to the IMF. How much more would need to be spent to get to a respectable 1.5% GDP growth? Double the deficit?
Maybe not something this extreme but with debt already heading towards an unsustainble path it's not clear that there is much scope for further spending, while markets may put pressure back onto Spain once again. This raises the prospect of a further bailout or transfers from other eurozone states, but as we pointed out at length yesterday, Lagarde is talking about something very different than removing austerity in that case.
I think an interesting question here is what Spain's policies would be at this point if it had its own currency.
ReplyDeleteIt could avoid so much fiscal consolidation and run a bigger deficit in order to stimulate growth and if the Peseta fell, oh well, that would be good for exports.
And if Spain had never give up its own currency, it would not have experienced the ten years of easy credit that led to the house-building bubble, so its Banking system would be in much better shape today.
as long as Spain stays in the Euro, the deficits will continue high until the debt is unsustainable.
ReplyDeleteIt seems that the new pain in Spain will derive from the current asset declaration regime, under which all those in Spain with assets abroad must declare these to the taxman. Fair enough, since other countries in the EU and the USA (FATCA, etc.)have this requirement. But this in Spain will no doubt be followed by a stiff "levy" or haircut on those assets given the worsening state of the economy and the lack of liquidity. This will destroy any thoughts of selling the million or more of unsold dwellings on the Spanish market since the property bubble burst. So forget that once important source of FDI.But beyond this there are well founded complaints to the EU Commission and petitions to the EU parliament demonstrating that the brutal penalties for even the smallest error in filing the declaration are discriminatory against expats and contravene not only Spanish law, but several EU norms. It is a matter of special concern to the towns and cities along the Mediterranean coasts that many expats see this as the last straw and are preparing to sell up, even accepting huge discounts on asking prices. Not clever at all.
ReplyDeleteIt seems that the new pain in Spain will derive from the current asset declaration regime, under which all those in Spain with assets abroad must declare these to the taxman. Fair enough, since other countries in the EU and the USA (FATCA, etc.)have this requirement. But this in Spain will no doubt be followed by a stiff "levy" or haircut on those assets given the worsening state of the economy and the lack of liquidity. This will destroy any thoughts of selling the million or more of unsold dwellings on the Spanish market since the property bubble burst. So forget that once important source of FDI.But beyond this there are well founded complaints to the EU Commission and petitions to the EU parliament demonstrating that the brutal penalties for even the smallest error in filing the declaration are discriminatory against expats and contravene not only Spanish law, but several EU norms. It is a matter of special concern to the towns and cities along the Mediterranean coasts that many expats see this as the last straw and are preparing to sell up, even accepting huge discounts on asking prices. Not clever at all.
ReplyDeleteSpain is not going to grow next year. The IMF and other forecast look way too optimistic. Nobody can indicate from which sector the growth should come (consumers will remain not consuming, equal investors and the government has to cut).
ReplyDeleteIt is kept alive as the markets are still buying Draghi's bluff and are extending his promises to the max. Plus Spain is succesfully robbing it pension and other funds and its bust banks with nothing to lose anyway are doubling down on the Sarko Trade. They are simply tying its banks and other financial institutions to the corpse of the state probably until these are also drowned.
And bankrestructuring will be Cyprus like this way. As things are set up a lot end as collareral up with the ECB (who will not write off is to be expected).